The Corporate diplomat: Debating the value of hard power vs soft power as a GC

Douglas Alexander, Pinsent Masons: I will first contextualise and attempt to define ‘soft power’ because, it is more often discussed than defined, and in that sense, I should probably declare an interest. In addition to many roles I hold, I have been a senior fellow at the Belfer Center in the Kennedy School of Government in Harvard over the last six years, and Joseph Nye, who coined the term ‘soft power’, has been a colleague of mine. Continue reading “The Corporate diplomat: Debating the value of hard power vs soft power as a GC”

Significant matters – Spring 2023

In-house course helps career-break lawyers re-enter profession

The Centre for Legal Leadership and Reignite Academy joined forces to run a one-day course for ‘career break’ lawyers seeking to re-enter the legal profession in an in-house role.

The course took place on 2 May in RPC’s office in London, and covered five different modules: the myths and expectations versus the reality of being an in-house lawyer; what it means to be commercial business partner; the breadths of topics an in-house lawyer has in their remit; the fundamentals of any commercial contract and how to make it work in practice.

The speakers at the event included Elaine Hutton, who moved from Clifford Chance to become GC at Channel 4 Television, Apple and most recently NTT Group’s cyber security division, and Luscinia Brown-Hovelt, who began her career as a corporate lawyer at Hogan Lovells before moving over to legal counsel in the retail and hospitality sector.

RPC’s head of commercial Jeremy Drew (pictured) said: ‘Moving in-house often requires a shift from being a specialist to a generalist – which can be daunting without the right support.

‘Attendees will benefit from learning from those who have made the transition and lawyers who for decades have worked with in-house lawyers in various sectors, at varying levels of seniority. This exposure, the workshops and time for one-on-one discussion will furnish attendees the insight and tools to move in-house, if that’s what’s right for them.’

One example is lawyer Vanessa Pringle, who began her career at Addleshaw Goddard where she spent over a decade but now serves in an in-house role at real estate investment company A.S.K partners.

Pringle said: ‘Lawyers, like everyone in the business, are encouraged and expected to think like entrepreneurial business owners which means the trajectory for your career is open, non-linear, and adaptive.’

Co-founder of the Reignite Academy, Lisa Unwin said: ‘The value of spending time with people who have walked a similar path to that you’re thinking of taking, is immeasurable. Post-event we expect attendees to have formed valuable connections which will see them not only make the right decision for their situation, but to be highly successful in making the transition.’

GCs ‘extremely concerned’ after SRA’s latest review of in-house sector

GCs are troubled by the Solicitor’s Regulation Authority’s lastest review of the in-house legal community, saying the regulator has understated the severity of risks faced by in-house lawyers.

The SRA surveyed more than 1,200 in-house lawyers to better understand their legal roles, focusing on how they support an ethical culture in their organisations, the challenges they face in meeting their professional obligations and how the regulator can help support them.

Former Lawtech UK director Jenifer Swallow shared a response to the review on LinkedIn, which at the time of going to press had been signed by more than 30 GCs, including Maaike de Bie, GC Powerlist regular and group GC of Vodafone group and Elizabeth Dyce, group GC at insuretech company Innovation Group Global.

While the GC response to SRA’s In-house Solicitors Thematic Review praises its focus on the in-house legal profession, the letter said the review understated the severity of the risks in an in-house environment and has produced inadequate conclusions.

‘It does not reflect the collective experience in-house or what was communicated by and to a number of us during the review, and it offers insufficient action and support in addressing concerns in the interests of stakeholders and society. The data gathered is useful, but the review’s conclusions are not supported by that data,’ the response said.

The GCs explicitly stated that they cannot agree with chief executive of the SRA Paul Philip on three main points: that the review findings are encouraging; regulatory risks identified in the in-house community are a minority issue; and that the risks relating to workloads and lack of training lead to poor decision making.

They urged the SRA to re-evaluate the tone and conclusions of the review urgently.

Swallow summarised several recommendations that GCs have proposed to the SRA, for example, instituting standards for in-house lawyer employment contracts; regulator outreach to employer-client boards; and detailed guidance materials and training for in-house lawyers on professional conflict.

They said the aim of the recommendations is to increase regulatory support for in-house lawyers without the only choice being to resign or reluctantly comply with professional and regulatory obligations.

A spokesperson for the SRA said: ‘We welcome all feedback on our thematic review. One of the key purposes of the report is to raise awareness of issues within the in-house sector, while highlighting both good practice and areas of concern. This report is very much a first step in our development of a range of bespoke resources to support the in-house community. We will continue to work with the in-house profession to help shape this.’

Five new firms appointed to Co-Op Bank panel

Five new firms have been appointed to provide legal services on The Co-Operative Bank’s second legal panel, following a formal review which began halfway through last year.

The legal panel will also comprise five reappointed firms, making up a team of 10 which will be in place until December 2025.

Addleshaw Goddard, Gateley, Hill Dickinson, Shoosmiths, and White & Case are the five new firms, while Clifford Chance, DLA Piper, Eversheds Sutherland, Hogan Lovells, and TLT have been selected to the panel for a second time.

However, six law firms from the 2015 panel have not made the cut this time, including Pinsent Masons, Allen & Overy and Mishcon de Reya. Other firms also not making a reappearance include Bates Wells, Matthew Arnold & Baldwin and Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner.

The Manchester-headquartered bank provides a wide range of services to approximately 2.7 million customers and 94,000 small and medium-sized businesses.

Commercial partner Luke Stubbs at Shoosmiths will lead his team, alongside banking and finance partner Liz Sweeney and restructuring partner Sarah Teal.

Stubbs said: ‘We submitted details of our expertise and capability and were delighted to be appointed by the bank along with a number of other leading firms.

‘Our aim is to help the bank deliver its long-term objectives and commitment to ethical, environmental and community matters – a shared vision that shapes our legal approach.’

Restructuring partner Tim Taylor will lead the Addleshaw team, supported by co-heads of the firm’s financial services sector Rosanna Bryant and Hugh Lauritsen.

Taylor said: ‘ Our team looks forward to bringing our technical expertise and sector experience to helping the bank deliver on its objectives and ambitions over the coming years.’

Moves that matter

  • Shell has announced the promotion of its current general counsel Philippa Bounds to legal director from June. Bounds has been at Shell for almost two decades and will replace Donny Ching, who has spent more than 33 years with Shell but is now stepping down from this role after nine years. Prior to joining Shell’s in-house legal team in 2005, Bounds was an associate at Shearman & Sterling for seven years following a two-year stint at Simmons & Simmons.
  • Switzerland-based luxury goods company Richemont has hired Thomas Loest from The Kraft Heinz Company as its global general counsel. Loest has held several in-house legal roles both London and elsewhere in Europe, including managing director and senior director at Nike and chief counsel for EMEA at US multinational personal care corporation Kimberly-Clark. He began his career in private practice at Hogan Lovells and Gleiss Lutz in Brussels.
  • M&G has announced that GC Powerlist alumnus Charlotte Heiss will join as its new general counsel and company secretary in June. She is currently group general counsel and company secretary at The Very Group and will bring more than two decades of legal and governance experience to M&G. Prior to that she spent 11 years at RSA Insurance Group as group general counsel and company secretary. She started her career as a managing associate at Linklaters.
  • Soft drinks manufacturer Suntory Beverage & Food has appointed Ewa Chappell as general counsel, where she will replace Mary Guest who has been promoted to deputy legal director. Chappell joins from premium drinks provider Diageo where she has spent seven years in several legal counsel-related roles. She joined the role in 2016 after a five-year run at Addleshaw Goddard where she trained as a solicitor.
  • After 16 years as general counsel and chief corporate officer at Balfour Beatty, Chris Vaughan has moved over to Whitbread. He will serve as the new general counsel company secretary, replacing Simon Barratt who is retiring after 18 years. Vaughan has held senior legal positions at SABMiller and InterContinental Hotels Group (formerly known as Six Continents) and qualified as a solicitor at Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer.
  • Family-run shipping business James Fisher and Sons has appointed Jean-François Bauer as group general counsel. Bauer spent almost 30 years at US technology company Schlumberger, starting as an attorney in Paris before receiving several promotions, including his most recent post as general counsel of commercial and contracts in London. In 2021, he had a brief two-year stint away from Schlumberger, where he was executive director of his own company JFJC Consulting and interim group general counsel of oil and gas company KCA Deutag.

A perfect storm

The insurance litigation world promises to be a busy one in 2023; an uptick in interest across novel areas – particularly ESG and technology – combined with the squeeze of an economic downturn provides the dramatic backdrop to a period which is likely to see a huge amount of activity. Continue reading “A perfect storm”

Catch me if you can

One of the greatest challenges that in-house legal teams confront from a data protection and cyber security perspective is staying up to date with trends and threats that seem to develop at an almost exponential rate. DLA Piper’s data protection and cyber security specialist Ross McKean explains: ‘Life was relatively simple in the early days of GDPR… since then there has been a rapid proliferation of laws, case law and guidance… so a key challenge for in-house lawyers is simply keeping up with all the new laws and legal developments.’ Continue reading “Catch me if you can”

A wholly subjective (but nonetheless definitive) guide to law firms from a $300m client on how to make a successful pitch*

In 2020, Teva Pharmaceuticals conducted a law firm selection process unprecedented in scale and sophistication within the profession (see ‘On notice: Teva’s entire $330m legal spend could go to one law firm’, The Legal 500, Summer 2019). Continue reading “A wholly subjective (but nonetheless definitive) guide to law firms from a $300m client on how to make a successful pitch*”

Terra Potter, Hexcel Corporation

Terra Potter (whose middle name is Cotta – IHL has seen the proof) proudly proclaims on LinkedIn that she originally hails from a cornfield outside Chicago and, while many lawyers claim to have had an unconventional path into a legal career, hers has been more so than most. Growing up in Rochelle, Illinois, she started working in kitchens, first as a dishwasher at the age of 14, before working her way up the cooking ladder, and so set her sights on a culinary career. A move to Hyde Park, New York and The Culinary Institute of America at the age of 17 had the unexpected consequence of a passion for the law. Continue reading “Terra Potter, Hexcel Corporation”

Reputation management and disputes: avoiding an avalanche of scrutiny

In recent times celebrity high profile litigation across the globe has taken place with actors, Gwyneth Paltrow’s successful defence of a claim arising from a ski collision on the slopes of Utah, and Jonny Depp winning his defamation lawsuit against Amber Heard, though losing an earlier case in London against UK newspapers in 2018. Such disputes have the potential to cause significant and sometimes business critical damage to the reputation of both the claimant and their intended target. In Ms Paltrow’s case she avoided her ski crash becoming a car crash and emerged reputation intact. But it is not always easy to achieve that outcome, given the inherent uncertainties of litigation. Continue reading “Reputation management and disputes: avoiding an avalanche of scrutiny”

Bermuda insurance regulation – responsible but facilitative environment encourages continued innovation

Bermuda is a leading re/insurance jurisdiction and continues to be a global leader in innovative risk transfer solutions, including ILS, climate risk finance and insurtech. In keeping with other jurisdictions Bermuda’s (re)insurance legal and regulatory environment continues to develop responsibly, to protect consumers while also supporting the industry and facilitating the continued development of new, inventive (re)insurance products. Continue reading “Bermuda insurance regulation – responsible but facilitative environment encourages continued innovation”

Establishing an open, mature and resilient insurance market in China

Since China’s accession to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in 2001, China has been making significant efforts to comply with its WTO commitments and has been progressively opening the Chinese insurance market to the world. Since 2017, China has been the world’s second largest insurance market, only next to the United States. Official data shows that market share for foreign invested insurance companies incorporated in China had increased from 3.5% in 2012 to 7.8% by 2021 and this figure had reached almost 20% by 2021 in major cities like Beijing and Shanghai. Continue reading “Establishing an open, mature and resilient insurance market in China”

Changing legislation in Switzerland: The new Swiss Federal Data Protection Act and updates on cybersecurity

1) 2023: An important year for data protection and cybersecurity in Switzerland

Swiss data protection law is primarily set out in the Federal Data Protection Act (FDPA) and the Data Protection Ordinance (FDPO). As Switzerland is a member neither of the EU nor the EEA, the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) does not apply to Swiss companies except under GDPR Art. 3 and potentially Swiss conflict of law rules. On the other hand, the revFDPA can apply to companies located outside of Switzerland. Continue reading “Changing legislation in Switzerland: The new Swiss Federal Data Protection Act and updates on cybersecurity”

Data protection and cybersecurity in Portugal: challenges ahead through 2023

In late February 2023, IBM Security X-Force Threat, a team at IBM that deals with cyber threats, published its 2023 report which brings together global-scale information gathered in 2022. The Intelligence Index report tracks cyberattack patterns from billions of pieces of data, including computer networks, servers, personal computers, mobile phones, incident responses, vulnerability databases and ways to exploit vulnerabilities. Continue reading “Data protection and cybersecurity in Portugal: challenges ahead through 2023”